REAP blog co-authored by: Ritu Bharadwaj (International Institute for Environment and Development), Emma Flaherty (REAP Secretariat), Céline Peyron Bista (Social Protection Department of the International Labour Organization), and Lorraine Youds (REAP Secretariat)
Introduction
Every year, on April 28th, the International Labour Organization World Day for Safety and Health at Work serves as a poignant reminder of the fundamental human right to a safe and healthy working environment. An ILO report recently alerted the world that 70.9 per cent of the global workforce is likely to be exposed to climate-related health hazards. This day holds heightened significance in least developed countries (LDCs) and small island developing states (SIDS), where communities are enduring the worst of climate change. Stories like those of Suman Owhal, a cane cutter from Kathawada village in Beed district, Maharashtra (India), who underwent a harrowing ordeal after needing to undergo a hysterectomy due to the impact of her work on her reproductive health, epitomise the dire need for comprehensive social protection amidst climate change. Suman's continuing struggles underscore the urgency for policymakers to prioritise the delivery of effective social protection, ensuring resilience and dignity for vulnerable workers, noting that women on the frontline of climate change face additional intersecting and compounding vulnerabilities.
Climate change as a stress multiplier
In LDCs and SIDS, the challenges people face are deepened by limited access to social protection; climate hazards precipitate a heightened risk for those already struggling in poverty or working within the informal economy. In low-income countries, only 8.5 per cent of children and 7.8 per cent of vulnerable persons are covered by social protection cash benefits. The absence of adequate social protection mechanisms and the stress climate change places on existing systems exposes workers to poverty and increases vulnerabilities, including unsafe working conditions, exploitation and abuse, and insufficient income to cover basic needs and healthcare. Furthermore, climate crises force distress migration, often trapping people in unsafe work conditions to survive and excluded from social protection measures. The repercussions of this desperate reality are far-reaching, affecting not only the migrants themselves but also those they are forced to leave behind.
Against this backdrop, the plight of countless women, some of whom face the heartbreaking consequences of a lack of adequate maternity and healthcare access and support, allows us to comprehend and forces us to confront the desperate realities faced by so many. These stories lay bare the urgent need for universal and comprehensive social protection in the face of climate change. The women highlighted in this study, and many others, find themselves caught in a web of exclusion from vital support systems, grappling with the consequences of climate migration, inadequate protection, and literally paying for the climate crisis with their wombs. This narrative resonates as a clarion call for governments and international policymakers to prioritise the delivery of effective social protection, ensuring resilience and dignity for those confronting the relentless onslaught of climate-related risks, as well as providing multiple benefits for governments.
Addressing intersecting vulnerabilities and mitigating risks
The vulnerability of LDCs and SIDS is heightened by elevated poverty rates, insufficient infrastructure, geographical isolation, and significant dependence on climate-sensitive sectors like agriculture and fisheries. By prioritising the most vulnerable in adaptation planning and providing timely and targeted shock-responsive assistance during crises, social protection programmes help mitigate the impacts of disasters and prevent further deterioration of livelihoods and social well-being. Effective safety and health initiatives can reduce the incidence of work-related morbidity, thus decreasing the combined impact on, and demand for, healthcare and social support services during disasters. This can contribute to social cohesion and development by enabling affected individuals to recover more quickly and reducing the disparities caused by emergencies.
Addressing crises ahead of their peak impact and integrating shock-responsive mechanisms into universal social protection prevents the deterioration of livelihoods and social well-being. This approach offers a cost-effective alternative to traditional crisis response. Moreover, adapting universal social protection systems to respond to crises aids in reducing vulnerabilities and facilitating climate adaptation over the longer term, thereby protecting lives, livelihoods, and development gains in times of crisis. Anticipatory cash transfer measures in Malawi and Senegal are one example of the efficacy of shock-responsive mechanisms as part of universal social protection. In Fiji, the World Food Programme and the Fijian Government set up innovative structures to provide cash assistance ahead of anticipated cyclones. By integrating elements from these models and strengthening social protection data, policymakers can tailor strategies to meet the specific needs of their populations, ensuring inclusive and resilient social protection systems.
The ILO Social Protection Floors Recommendation, 2012, underscores the human right to social security and emphasises the important role it has in reducing poverty, promoting equality, and supporting the transition from informal to formal employment. Similarly, the ‘Getting Ahead of Disasters’ Charter, launched at a Presidential event on COP28’s Relief Recovery and Peace Day, outlines principles for collaborative action to better manage risks and protect vulnerable populations from climate-related disasters. By aligning with these frameworks, governments and policymakers can foster comprehensive risk management, enhance early action, and mobilise finance to protect development gains and minimise disaster impacts.
Addressing challenges
In the pursuit of proactive measures to mitigate the devastating impacts of climate change, it is crucial to emphasise the critical link between the provision of social protection (including to respond to shock), and the incidence of worker mortality and morbidity amidst the added stress of climate impacts. Recognising that universal and robust social protection policies and systems contribute to the resilience of communities and economies, concerted efforts are needed to integrate universal social protection with plans to act ahead of climate-related crises.
Acknowledging the inadequacies of current financing in addressing the escalating impacts of climate change and the need to extend social protection, the ‘Getting Ahead of Disasters’ Charter underscores the necessity for collaborative endeavours spanning governmental, intergovernmental, workers' organisations and private sectors, as well as vertically from the local to the global. International initiatives are already underway to advocate for early action and predictable financing mechanisms conducive to comprehensive risk management.
As exemplified by the principles outlined in the Charter, the shared objective is to proactively address climate-related disasters through enhancing the use of finance, aligning long-term financial strategies across various sectors, maximising pre-arranged finance (PAF) to expedite response mechanisms, strengthening delivery systems to ensure timely assistance, and prioritising community-centric approaches to ensure that approaches are sustainable and effective. By integrating these principles in universal social protection systems aligned with the Social Protection Floors Recommendation, 2012 (No.202), societies can bolster resilience and ensure that individuals and communities receive adequate support before, during, and after disasters. This proactive stance not only mitigates the potential impacts of climate crises but also fosters a more inclusive and resilient society capable of navigating future challenges with greater efficacy and compassion.
Conclusion
To address the pressing needs posed by the growing impact of climate change, the public sector national governments and key stakeholders, working with international organisations, must prioritise and lead the development of universal and adequate social protection as a cornerstone of their climate adaptation strategies. By embracing the principles outlined in the ILO Social Protection Floors Recommendation, 2012, and the Getting Ahead of Disasters Charter, systemic change can be catalysed and better protection for vulnerable populations can be provided. Moving forward, it is imperative to offer a detailed set of actionable policy recommendations, ranging from securing international and domestic funding and facilitating the transition of workers to the formal economy to integrating shock-responsive elements into universal social protection systems. These recommendations will serve as a valuable guide for policymakers, government agencies, international actors and advocates in the field, ensuring the creation of more resilient and equitable societies in the face of unprecedented environmental change.